Home › Features › Snapshots › State and the Stateswoman

State and the Stateswoman

How Hillary Clinton Reshaped U.S. Foreign Policy — But Not the World
Michael E. O'Hanlon
January 29, 2013
Article Summary and Author Biography

Hillary Clinton has had a solid tenure as secretary of state. There have been plenty of accomplishments and no major failures, but nor has there been any world-historical Clinton Doctrine. More than anything else, her continued effort to create one might just lead her to the Oval Office.

MICHAEL O’HANLON is a Senior Fellow at The Brookings Institution and coauthor (with Martin Indyk and Kenneth Lieberthal) of Bending History: Barack Obama’s Foreign Policy.

Print Email
Essay
Leading Through Civilian Power
Hillary Rodham Clinton

To meet the range of challenges facing the United States and the world, Washington will have to strengthen and amplify its civilian power abroad. Diplomacy and development must work in tandem, offering countries the support to craft their own solutions.

Secretary of State Clinton during an interview. (Gary Cameron / Courtesy Reuters)

As Secretary of State Hillary Clinton prepares to hand the reins of foreign policy over to Senator John Kerry, her legacy is a matter of hot debate. To be sure, with much of the Middle East in turmoil and U.S. relations with Russia and China shifting, broad assessments of her tenure, no matter how heated, are only provisional. Even so, some of the most important and enduring elements of the Clinton years -- steadiness and pragmatism coupled with a reinvigoration of ties with Europe and the so-called rebalancing with Asia -- are clear...

Registration Required: Log in to continue reading

To continue reading, you must be a registered user or Foreign Affairs subscriber.

Please log in below or register with ForeignAffairs.com.

Related

Essay, Spring 1979
Toward Presidential Control of the State Department
Laurence H. Silberman

This article challenges the notion that it is appropriate for Foreign Service officers to routinely occupy senior policymaking positions in the State Department. As a recent "political" ambassador who has also served at a senior level in domestic departments of our government, I confess that I ended my ambassadorial stint with less than friendly feelings toward the Foreign Service as a whole. Since then, reflecting as dispassionately as possible on my own observations and looking with some care into past history, I have concluded that the frictions that have arisen almost continuously between the Service and successive Presidents (and their political appointees) have their roots deep in the system of appointments itself-and that they lend themselves to constructive remedies.

Read
Essay, Oct 1970
What is to be Done?
John Franklin Campbell

American foreign policy is changing, but the machinery of government is not changing with it. As we try to enter what President Nixon has called an era of negotiation, it is time to ask whether the nation is well served by the immense foreign affairs bureaucracies that have grown up in Washington over the past quarter-century. Could institutional reform give new coherence to our foreign policy? How these questions are answered may well determine the success or failure of American diplomacy in the seventies.

Read
Postscript, April 30, 2009
Jonestown
I. M. Destler

The Obama administration has promised to revamp the National Security Council, but so far it has not delivered.

Read