Home › Books & Reviews › Capsule Reviews › Nuclear Arguments: The Major Debates On Strategic Nuclear Weapons And Arms Control; Defending Deterrence: Managing The ABM Treaty Regime Into The 21st Century

Nuclear Arguments: The Major Debates On Strategic Nuclear Weapons And Arms Control; Defending Deterrence: Managing The ABM Treaty Regime Into The 21st Century

Edited by Lynn Eden and Steven E. Miller
Edited by Antonia Handler Chayes and Paul Doty
Reviewed by William G. Hyland
Winter 1989/90
Nuclear Arguments: The Major Debates On Strategic Nuclear Weapons And Arms Control
Edited by Lynn Eden and Steven E. Miller
Cornell University Press
1989
338 pp.
$49.95
Defending Deterrence: Managing The ABM Treaty Regime Into The 21st Century
Edited by Antonia Handler Chayes and Paul Doty
Pergamon-Brassey's
1989
286 pp.
$32.00
Login or Register to leave a comment.

These two Cambridge-based books both show Paul Doty's fine sensibility. Eden and Miller seek to explicate the underlying issues in the nuclear debate, complete with a model on a computer disk; the effort comes late--just as the nuclear issue recedes-but is nonetheless welcome. The Chayes-Doty volume is a meticulous treatment by distinguished contributors of a very specific question: assuming that nuclear deterrence will continue to depend on second-strike retaliation, how can the assuredness, provided by the paucity of strategic defense on both sides, be preserved?

Related

Review Essay, Jul/Aug 2004
The Fire Last Time
Scott Snyder

Going Critical offers an insiders' view of the deal struck with North Korea in 1994 and a core lesson for the Bush administration: there's no substitute for negotiation.

Read
Essay, Summer 1985
New Zealand's Security Policy
David Lange

New Zealand's decision to exclude nuclear weapons from its territory, and the American response to that decision, have raised serious questions about the character and management of the ANZUS (Australia-New Zealand-United States) alliance and the security of the South Pacific.

Read
Essay, Jan/Feb 1996
The Second Coming of the Nuclear Age
Fred Charles Iklé

Nuclear weapons were used for the first and only time in World War II, and the world has grown accustomed to their nonuse. But the overwhelming deterrent forces that worked during the Cold War will not provide protection against the new threats: terrorism and catastrophic accident. The arsenals and mindsets of the past half-century present a formidable barrier to change, but the United States must lead the way in preventing nuclear weapons from becoming acceptable.

Read
Cover image

In the Magazine

November/December 2009 / 6, 88
Essay
In the Quicksands of Somalia
Bronwyn Bruton

Washington's repeated attempts to bring peace to Somalia with state-building initiatives have failed, even backfired. It should renounce political intervention and encourage local development without trying to improve governance.
Read