Perfidious Albion: The Abandonment Of Hong Kong 1997
In this provocative study an American journalist argues that Britain has by default allowed China to determine the shape of the institutions that will govern Hong Kong after its reversion to Chinese sovereignty in 1997. The United States, he says, as the largest foreign investor in the colony, ought to play a more active role in shaping future developments in Hong Kong by adopting a more generous immigration policy and by passing the U.S.-Hong Kong Policy Act now before Congress. There is merit in McGurn's analysis but his picture of the situation seems too bleak. With the rapid economic development of Hong Kong and neighboring Kwangdung province, any future Chinese leadership will have a strong interest in maintaining Hong Kong as a financial and trade center.
Related
Christopher Patten's new book goes beyond Hong Kong to offer a sensible middle ground in the debate over the link between culture and Asia's rise -- and fall.
Long before Hong Kong's scheduled July 1 reversion to China, the American media decided that the place was in grave danger, if not beyond salvation. The American doomsayers overlook that Hong Kong's borders, currency, and international memberships will remain intact. And although some civil liberties may be rolled back, an objective examination of China's behavior during the transition suggests that changes will be narrow rather than sweeping. Claims that post-1997 Hong Kong will cease to be the crossroads between East and West are alarmist.
Since Mao Zedong's death in 1976, and particularly since the rise of Deng Xiaoping in 1978, the post-Mao leaders of China have sought to develop a new strategy and new institutions for modernizing China. In the economy, they have sought a more decentralized, quasi-market socialist system better suited to Chinese conditions than the highly centralized, Soviet-type system they adopted in 1949. Perhaps the most significant step has been a de facto decollectivization of agriculture.

Sign-up for free weekly updates from ForeignAffairs.com.