Home › Books & Reviews › Capsule Reviews › Strengthening Palestinian Public Institutions: Report of an Independent Task Force; The Transformation of Palestinian Politics: From Revolution to State-Building

Strengthening Palestinian Public Institutions: Report of an Independent Task Force; The Transformation of Palestinian Politics: From Revolution to State-Building

Edited by Michel Rocard
Barry Rubin
Reviewed by By L. Carl Brown
March/April 2000
Print Email
Login or Register to leave a comment.

Sign-up for free weekly updates from ForeignAffairs.com.
Edited by Michel Rocard
Council on Foreign Relations Press
1999
123 pp.
087609258X
$7.00
Barry Rubin
Harvard University Press
1999
288 pp.
0674000714
$29.95

The Council on Foreign Relations task force on Palestinian public institutions included four Europeans who have served as prime minister and three as foreign minister, as well as former members of Congress Nancy Kassebaum Baker and Lee Hamilton, and other high-ranking Europeans and Americans. They personify a powerful Euro-American concern to make Palestinian institutions work. But not surprisingly, this quasi-official report offers somewhat bland findings, balancing "achievements" with "challenges" and largely ignoring the overall political context surrounding the Palestinian Authority. Fortunately, that missing context is presented in Rubin's book -- a refreshing account that is moderately sanguine without stinting on any of the several dark spots. Rubin also manages a balanced presentation of all the many different players in this ongoing Palestinian drama -- Yasir Arafat, the PLO, Hamas, the many Israeli political groupings, the Arab states, the United States, and the international community. With nine detailed but succinct chapters, this book is an eminently readable achievement.

Related

Postscript, February 8, 2010
The Hamas Conundrum
Michael Herzog

Since winning elections in 2006, Hamas has demonstrated that it cannot be part of an Israeli-Palestinian peace process, nor part of a Palestinian body politic based on democracy and free elections. But can policymakers deny the group the ability to play the spoiler?

Read
Essay, Mar/Apr 2006
Do Targeted Killings Work?
Daniel Byman

One of the tactics Israel has used in responding to terrorism has been to seek out and kill individual enemies. Now Washington has started doing the same. The United States and Israel face different circumstances, however, and so the Bush administration should think twice before proceeding.

Read
Essay, Fall 1982
The Middle East: A Turning Point?: Begin's Rhetoric and Sharon's Tactics
Amos Perlmutter

If one looks long enough at recent events in Lebanon, one can see emerging the new face of Israel's Begin government, a face markedly different from the first government of Menachem Begin. That first Begin government, which toppled a decaying and increasingly ineffectual Labor Party, had its moderate and restraining elements whose crowning achievement was the Camp David Accords. The then Defense Minister Ezer Weizman, along with Foreign Minister Moshe Dayan, were the reins on Begin's often frightening rhetoric, steering Begin away from the effects of his worst instincts.

Read