The French Challenge: Adapting to Globalization
The 1967 book Le Defi americain (The American challenge) became a classic by urging Europe to modernize or succumb to corporate America. Gordon and Meunier explain why today's challenge, American-led globalization, is particularly agonizing for France. But they also argue that France has been adapting to globalization better than is commonly recognized. They show meaningful changes in economic policy and corporate culture (driven by European integration as well as globalization) while acknowledging that falling trade barriers strengthen the demand for protectionism in certain sectors (notably, the "cultural exception"). Overall, public opinion is "neither unambiguously enthusiastic about nor unremittingly hostile to globalization." This assertion seems contradicted by the unremitting hostility to globalization found in much French political rhetoric. But the book attributes this paradox to a strategy of "globalization by stealth": French politicians cater to their "fascinated but afraid" public by quietly pushing the country into the global economy while loudly denouncing "the dangers of unbridled globalization driven by jungle capitalism," in the words of Chirac. Readers familiar with French history will find little new territory here (although the rich trove of public opinion polls offers some surprises). Anyone wanting a primer on contemporary France or an intelligent exegesis of the Franco-American dynamic, however, will find The French Challenge a lively read.
Related
Anti-Americanism and a stubborn Gaullist independence in foreign policy have often marked French political discourse. These traits are coming to the fore once again in France's wildly popular antiglobalization movement. Today, a complex mix of political, economic, and cultural reasons explains the French resistance to "Anglo-Saxon global capitalism." If sustained, France's stand could become a model for other countries seeking an alternative to the new, American-style world economy.
The French always seem to be opposing the United States on some issue or other. They coddle Saddam Hussein and denounce American "cultural imperialism." Why is France so difficult to deal with? It is, quite simply, in a bad mood, unsure of its place and status in a new world. The French are jealous of America, which seems to run the world; afraid of globalization, which threatens to erode their culture; and ambivalent about European unification, which might drown out their voice. France must meet these challenges while struggling with a cumbersome statist economy and a rising extreme right. To do it all, France must transcend itself.
President Charles de Gaulle in discussing current Franco-American relations often focuses upon the prewar neutrality of the United States as well as upon his wartime differences with President Franklin D. Roosevelt. In doing so he conjures up the image of an unreliable American ally. His recollections have also pushed into the background of public memory the two years before France's tragic collapse in June 1940, when, in the words of former Premier Edouard Daladier, "President Roosevelt was for France a very great and noble friend." As Premier during those years, Daladier witnessed at first hand the American President's efforts to help France order some 4,000 American combat planes to rebuild French defenses against the imminent attack of Hitler's vastly superior air power. Hitherto the details of the story have been wrapped in the secrecy of American and French archives, private papers and personal memories, but it can now be seen that Roosevelt concentrated his principal effort on that aid because he believed that in no other way could the United States strengthen France so significantly. Neither Morgenthau's monetary agreements nor the sale of machine tools and raw materials would do so much to increase French capacity to resist Nazi aggression. Roosevelt was ready to go as far as possible in spite of isolationist opposition to the delivery of planes to France because of his further conviction that, despite the Neutrality Act, the frontiers of the United States extended to the Rhine.

Sign-up for free weekly updates from ForeignAffairs.com.