Dreams of Peace and Freedom: Utopian Moments in the Twentieth Century
To anyone with a flame of utopian hope still flickering in his or her soul, this moving, wise, and passionate book can only be a blessing. Winter has no illusions either about the horrors of the twentieth century or about grand utopias that rely on the state for the improvement of humanity. What interests him here are "minor utopias," whose importance he stresses in reaction against the prevalence of "catastrophic history," which highlights "the monstrous and the shocking," and of "superior history," which confuses "cynicism with wisdom." Many of the twentieth-century minor utopias failed, but they represented moments of hope -- and some were at least partly successful in changing aspects of the human condition for the better. Winter surveys twentieth-century visions of peace, human rights, direct democracy, and global citizenship. This brand of "alternative history" may, like Winter's utopias, be minor, but, like them, it is also necessary.
Related
Astonishing events in Czechoslovakia were only the latest in a series of changes in the communist world that took the outside world by surprise. The thaw and Hungarian rebellion of 1956, China's break with the Soviet Union and immersion in internal convulsion, and even the rejection of Russian control in Rumania-all were largely unforeseen (with only a few exceptions) even by expert opinion in the West, Like military planners who prepare for the last war, commentators on communist affairs in their preoccupation with accounting for the last surprise have often left the public unprepared for the next one. The concept of monolithic totalitarianism, based on parallels between Hitler and the later Stalin, ill prepared us to expect rebellion in Hungary; preoccupation with the Sino-Soviet split (which was only belatedly thought to be important, and then rapidly promoted into being the controlling factor in the divided communist world of the sixties) distracted us from any expectation of liberal deviation in Czechoslovakia.
The Clinton administration erred grievously in threatening intervention in the northern Balkans (Bosnia, Serbia, Croatia) and then quailing when it was needed. But in the southern Balkans (Macedonia, Albania, Greece, Turkey), U.S. diplomacy has been successful, particularly compared with the clownish efforts of European nations. Capable U.S. envoys have worked hard to reverse the growing polarization of Greece and Turkey. Moreover, U.S. support has helped reinforce the fragile geographic firewall, Macedonia, thus preventing a wider regional war.
Europeans enter the 1980s experiencing, for the first time since the cold war, a deep sense of concern--and even fear in some quarters--for the preservation of peace on their Continent. The decade began with speeches by European leaders, including President Giscard d'Estaing and Pope John Paul II, stressing the risks of a new world war, and polls conducted in several European countries throughout 1980 echoed similar qualms.

Sign-up for free weekly updates from ForeignAffairs.com.