Planet India: How the Fastest-Growing Democracy Is Transforming America and the World
With India now developing almost as rapidly as China, we can expect a slew of ecstatic studies in which exuberance replaces analytic rigor and even common sense. Kamdar is convinced that India will shortly be recognized as the model for late-developing countries. The United States cannot serve as a model, she believes, because it absorbs far too much of the earth's resources and produces too much of its pollution. Japan cannot because it has a uniquely homogenous population. Kamdar makes her case for India by quoting interviews with Indian leaders and citing a bevy of facts and figures. In the latter part of the book, she does introduce some negative factors, particularly when she addresses the problems of India's 600,000 villages, its urban slums, and the millions of Indians who are living on less than $2 a day. Overall, however, the book captures a certain spirit of Indian optimism that sets India apart from other late-developing countries -- including China, where there is greater attention to problems and less counting of chickens before they hatch.
Related
For some months, 1966 promised to be a year of significant albeit gradual change in American policy toward Communist China. In a strange and paradoxical fashion, the emotional issues of the Viet Nam War opened the way for the most sober, responsible and even-handed public discussion of China since the Communists came to power. At Congressional hearings and in the mass media, scholars and leaders of opinion have dispassionately calculated the possibilities for change, and Administration leaders have in their customarily guarded language intimated that change was not impossible. Most significant of all, the American public demonstrated a gratifying degree of maturity by forgetting the old passions and asking for only facts and analyses about the new China. Our national mood was increasingly one of believing that with prudence and wisdom it would be possible to work toward gradually incorporating China into responsible world relationships.
Are The Tiananmen Papers authentic? What do they tell us? The truth could overturn an official history that has stymied political reform in China for a decade.
Christopher Patten's new book goes beyond Hong Kong to offer a sensible middle ground in the debate over the link between culture and Asia's rise -- and fall.

Sign-up for free weekly updates from ForeignAffairs.com.