Seduced by Secrets: Inside the Stasi's Spy-Tech World
This book includes everything you ever wanted to know about the East German security service's penetration into West Germany's scientific, industrial, and military secrets, and more. Macrakis grew up in East Germany, but only later, as a historian of science, teaching in the West, did she become fascinated with the world of spying and the science the East Germans obsessively sought to steal together with the organization and technology they applied to the task. The first half of her book features who was involved and how they did it; the second half focuses on the techniques and, particularly, the curious, fiction-inspiring tools they used to film, eavesdrop, follow, communicate, and disrupt. Her research, both archival and based on interviews, including with the famous East German spy chief Markus Wolf, is prodigious; the detail is somewhat overwhelming and, at times, repetitive. But one comes away from the book with a well-tutored sense of the scale and the precise nature of East German and, by extension, Soviet industrial and military espionage. Macrakis' larger point emerges only briefly and between the lines: that in the nature of the enterprise, what the East Germans and the Soviets did was not so different from what their Western counterparts did -- but that in the case of the East Germans, the preoccupation with secrecy as an end in itself and with technology as the means to nearly all ends was ultimately dysfunctional.
Related
The Greater Good
HANS-GEORG WIECK
In his essay reviewing James Critchfield's book Partners at the Creation ("Berlin to Baghdad," July/August 2004), Timothy Naftali devalues and disparages the early postwar cooperation between the CIA and what later became West Germany's Bundesnachrichtendienst (BND), its federal intelligence service. Naftali asserts that the intelligence delivered by General Reinhard Gehlen's organization and its successor, the BND, was "of no significance" and of "questionable" value.
Although Russia has projected itself more forcefully on the world stage since the beginning of the Putin era, its foreign policy still lacks any sort of grand strategic vision. Russian leaders continue to squabble over issues from NATO expansion to the world economy. But they are particularly concerned about Russia's identity, especially with regard to the post-Soviet states. If the Bush administration fails to devise a coherent policy of its own toward its former rival, it may face serious problems down the road.
Gorbachev's new thinking is based on the belief that military power is not the only way to national security, and that there is a link between national and mutual security. The revolution in foreign policy thinking has been most profound at the level of policy concepts, and has been based on a realization that the real threat to the USSR comes from the weakening of the economy due to excessive military spending. Notes how the ideas underpinning the foreign policy revolution have existed for the last decade, and how the evidence suggests that the change is genuine.

Sign-up for free weekly updates from ForeignAffairs.com.