Skip to main content
March/April 2021 cover
Cart Subscribe Sign in
Explore Subscribe
  • Sections
  • Account
  • Current Issue
  • Archive
  • Anthologies
  • Books & Reviews
  • Interviews
  • This Day in History
  • Author Directory
  • Events
  • Career Center
  • Coronavirus
  • U.S. Foreign Policy
  • Economics
  • Security
  • Environment
  • Climate Change
  • Biden Administration
  • War & Military Strategy
  • China
  • Middle East
  • India
  • Russia & FSU
  • United States
  • Iran
  • Turkey
  • United Kingdom
  • View All Regions >
  • Essays
  • Snapshots
  • Articles with Audio
  • Interviews
  • Responses
  • Review Essays
  • Capsule Reviews
  • Reading Lists
  • Ask the Experts
  • Foreign Affairs This Week
  • The Backstory
  • Foreign Affairs Today
  • Weekend Read
  • Books & Reviews
  • Foreign Affairs Career Adviser
  • Customer Service
  • Subscriber Resources
  • Feedback
  • Institutional Subscriptions
  • Gift a Subscription
  • Contact

Follow Us

Magazine Become a Member Save up to 55% on Foreign Affairs
Subscribe Sign In
Explore

  • Current Issue
  • Archive
  • Books & Reviews
  • Anthologies
  • Newsletters
Search
Subscribe
Subscribe Sign in
January/February 2018 Issue

The Undead Past

The Undead Past
  • January/February 2018
  • 01 America’s Original Sin
  • 02 From Nazism to Never Again
  • 03 Don’t Speak, Memory
  • 04 China’s Cover-Up
  • 05 All Is Not Forgiven
  • 06 Rwanda’s Recovery

What's Inside

January/February 2018
Sign in and save to read later
Save to Pocket
Share
Print this article
Save
Share on Twitter
Share on Facebook
Send by email
Get a link

How do nations handle the sins of the fathers and mothers? Take genocide, or slavery, or political mass murder. After such knowledge, what forgiveness—and what way forward? The Germans have a word for it, of course: Vergangenheitsbewältigung, or “coming to terms with the past.” But the concept is applicable far beyond the Nazis—as Americans belatedly recognized when Robert E. Lee shot to the front of the culture wars last August after the riots in Charlottesville, Virginia. To put the debates over memorializing the Confederacy in context, this issue’s lead package explores how various countries have handled similar problems. There have been all too many crimes in all too many places, but six cases stand out—two of genocide, two of political mass murder, and two of enduring racial oppression. Individually, the articles here delve into how each country has processed its tragic past. Together, they reveal interesting patterns and lessons.  To kick things off, Annette Gordon-Reed considers the United States’ troubled racial history, from the founding to the present. Slavery may be gone, she points out, but its underlying ideology lives on. Then, Richard Evans traces Germany’s evolving attitudes toward the Nazi era, from initial postwar sympathy to mature critical engagement—with the contemporary resurgence of right-wing populist nationalism as an unfortunate coda to a generally heartening story. Nikita Petrov and Orville Schell look at Russia’s and China’s problematic responses to Stalinism and Maoism, respectively. Petrov finds an official soft-pedaling of the Soviet regime’s horrors, combined with a patriotic celebration of Russia’s authoritarian past. Schell finds something even worse—an airbrushing of Mao’s horrors out of the historical picture by later Chinese Communist leaders. Sisonke Msimang casts a cool eye on South Africa’s truth-and-reconciliation process, arguing that although it provided a useful public forum for victims to find answers and perpetrators to seek forgiveness, it failed to dismantle the enduring structural racial and economic inequalities of apartheid. And Phil Clark, finally, assesses Rwanda’s ongoing recovery from genocide—a success story in many respects, such as the creative legal processing of perpetrators and impressive official education programs, but playing out under the Kagame regime’s authoritarianism. Worst practices are easy to identify: denying what actually happened. Best practices are more scattered, but one country leads the field. Germany’s crimes rank with the worst in history. But at least, over time, the right lessons were indeed learned, and responsible engagement with the past has become a new national tradition. (One example is the Stolpersteine plaques—two of which are pictured on the cover, remembering Martin and Sophie Happ, who were murdered at Auschwitz in 1943.) Perhaps facing a problem so directly and brutally that you coin an actual word for it is a smart idea after all.

—Gideon Rose, Editor

More:
Politics & Society

Most-Read Articles

Great-Power Competition Is Coming to Africa

The United States Needs to Think Regionally to Win

Marcus Hicks, Kyle Atwell, and Dan Collini

China Is Not Ten Feet Tall

How Alarmism Undermines American Strategy

Ryan Hass

The Stories China Tells

The New Historical Memory Reshaping Chinese Nationalism

Jessica Chen Weiss

Foreign Policy for Pragmatists

How Biden Can Learn From History in Real Time

Gideon Rose

Get the Magazine

Save up to 55%

on Foreign Affairs magazine!

Subscribe

Foreign Affairs

Weekly Newsletter

Get in-depth analysis delivered right to your inbox

About

About Us Staff Careers Events Work at Foreign Affairs

Contact

Customer Service Contact Us Submissions Permissions Advertise Press Center Leave Us Feedback Frequently Asked Questions

Subscription

Subscriptions Group Subscriptions My Account Give a Gift Donate Download iOS App Newsletters Download Android App

Follow

Graduate School Forum

Council on Foreign Relations

From the
publishers of
Foreign Affairs

The Most:

Recent Shared Viewed

Cyber Week in Review: March 5, 2021

by Adam Segal

Women This Week: Women Soldiers in Saudi Arabia

by Guest Blogger for Women Around the World

As Crisis Deepens in Ethiopia, Need for Committed Diplomatic Response Grows

by Michelle Gavin

The Link Between Foreign Languages and U.S. National Security

Aung San Suu Kyi’s Major Speech on Rakhine State

by Joshua Kurlantzick

Creating a State Department Office for American State and Local Diplomacy

by Alyssa Ayres

Books & Reports

The U.S. War in Afghanistan

by Zachary Laub

The 2020 Election by the Numbers

by James M. Lindsay

Published by the Council on Foreign Relations

Privacy Policy Terms of Use

©2021 Council on Foreign Relations, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

This site uses cookies to improve your user experience. Click here to learn more.