In This Review

Trotsky: An Appreciation of His Life
Trotsky: An Appreciation of His Life
By Joel Carmichael
St. Martin, 1975, 512 pp.
Avocat de Trotsky
Avocat de Trotsky
By Gérard Rosenthal
Laffont, 1975, 330 pp.

Carmichael's new, expansive, and swiftly moving life story of Trotsky, while not replacing that by Isaac Deutscher, is a sympathetic and critical portrait of his career, personality, and character rather than an analysis of his thought and works. Living on theories, and thus on illusions, his exile and death have the inevitability of classic tragedy. The rather slight book by Rosenthal, who was Trotsky's secretary and lawyer, adds interesting material on the years of exile.