Joan Peters undertook a massive research job in order to make the case against Arab claims that Palestine was peopled "from time immemorial" by Arabs, who were dispossessed and driven out by Jewish immigrants. It is a long, involved story which deserves a reading even though it is one-sided and repetitious and proves less than it claims. Some of the main arguments of Avneri's monograph run parallel to those of Miss Peters, such as that Jewish settlement attracted rather than displaced Arabs and that purchases of land by Zionists were mainly from Arab landowners eager to sell. His book is much leaner and less shrill in tone, although it is also aimed at making a political case.
Get the best of Foreign Affairs' book reviews delivered to you.