In This Review

Intelligence and Strategic Surprises
Intelligence and Strategic Surprises
By Ariel Levite
220 pp, Columbia University Press, 1987

This small book is thought-provoking if ultimately unconvincing. It launches a broadside against the now conventional wisdom about surprise attack, based in significant measure on Roberta Wohlstetter's classic work on Pearl Harbor: that warning was available but not grasped because of organizational and psychological barriers. Reexamining Pearl Harbor and Midway, Levite argues that in fact sufficient warning indicators were not available before Pearl Harbor. Two cases, however, are a modest basis for generalizing, especially for an author as careful about method as Levite. More important, he comes close to arguing a tautology: if warning was not grasped, the indicators must have been insufficient.