Reviewing together these two very different books serves to underscore that in the Middle East, religion and international politics are inseparable. Each book does a splendid job of tracing the origins and development of a religious doctrine and its impact on the mundane world. Anderson's subject is the belief by an important number of Christians that the state of Israel is ordained by God -- part of his plan leading to the end times. The roots of this "Christian Zionism" go back to the nineteenth-century split between the "historical/critical" and the "literal/prophetic" approaches in Christian theology. Cook traces fourteen centuries of Muslim jihadist theology, including the modern liberal interpretation that depicts the principle of jihad as equivalent to the Christian just-war doctrine. Anderson leans more toward the social history of Christian Zionism, while Cook, hewing closer to doctrinal changes, provides a fine study in intellectual history. Each author brings a dispassionate appreciation to a subject so often fraught with misrepresentation, and each book is, quite simply, the most readable and best on its subject.
Get the best of Foreign Affairs' book reviews delivered to you.