"It is never easy to cleanly distinguish freedom and duty, consent and bondage, choice and compulsion.” So writes Abu-Lughod, an anthropologist with three decades of field experience in the Middle East, reflecting on the question of women’s rights and status in Muslim-majority societies. This elegantly written and compelling book contends that women in such places suffer more from the inequities of globalization than from patriarchy. Indeed, she suggests that humanitarianism represents the new face of colonialism, sometimes unwittingly -- arguing, for example, that well-intentioned Western feminism has served as a cover for the U.S.-led war against the Taliban in Afghanistan, a military action she deems to be deeply flawed. She criticizes a genre of writing about the Muslim world that she terms “pulp nonfiction”: sensationalized accounts of rape, oppression, and brutality that are suffused with a kind of titillating sexuality. She presents an interesting and original analysis of Muslim feminism and tells the complex life stories of a number of ordinary Egyptian women, revealing them to be far more than simple tales of oppression. Abu-Lughod’s message is valuable, but she asks readers to evince a sensitivity to nuance that has taken her 30 years to acquire.
In This Review
In This Review
Most Read Articles
The Demolition of U.S. Diplomacy
Not Since Joe McCarthy Has the State Department Suffered Such a Devastating Blow
Disaster in the Desert
Why Trump’s Middle East Plan Can’t Work
There Will Be a One-State Solution
But What Kind of State Will It Be?
Turkey’s Endgame in Syria
What Erdogan Wants
Nowhere to Go
How Governments in the Americas Are Bungling the Migration Crisis