Courtesy Reuters

The Settlement Obsession

Both Israel and the United States Miss the Obstacles to Peace

Purchase Review

On taking office in 2009, U.S. President Barack Obama put Israeli settlements at the center of U.S. policy in the Middle East. In Washington's view, a complete construction freeze in the West Bank and East Jerusalem became not only desirable but also a prerequisite to Israeli-Palestinian peace negotiations. Previous U.S. administrations of both parties had never taken such a stance, and in fact, there had been years of negotiations (not least at Camp David in 2000 and after the Annapolis meeting in 2007) while Israeli settlement activity continued. But the Obama administration stuck to its demand, and when Israel refused to freeze construction, 2009 and much of 2010 went by without negotiations. This only changed in November 2010, when the White House abandoned the entire approach and began to search for a new one.

This single-minded focus on a construction freeze was clearly a mistake in the sense that it failed: the Israeli government did not agree to a freeze in East Jerusalem. Nor could any earlier Israeli governments have accepted such a demand, even if they, like Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, had been open to partial or time-limited freezes in the West Bank. John Kerry (D-Mass.), chair of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, expressed the situation well when he said in April 2011, "I was opposed to the prolonged effort on the settlements in a public way because I never thought it would work and, in fact, we have wasted a year and a half on something that for a number of

Log in or register for free to continue reading.

Registered users get access to one free article every month.

In This Review

Occupation of the Territories: Israeli Soldiers' Testimonies 2000-2010
Breaking the Silence
Breaking the Silence, 2010
431 pp.
The Settlers: And the Struggle Over the Meaning of Zionism
Gadi Taub
Yale University Press, 2010
240 pp. $32.50

Browse Related Articles on {{}}

{{ | number}} Articles Found

  • {{bucket.key_as_string}}